|
By: Jonathan Chevreau
Financial Post
June 27, 2002
The gallows humour in brokerage offices yesterday over WorldCom
Inc. involved word-play like "World Con."
Thus, in a note, Don Coxe dubbed the latest accounting scandal
the World Con Job.
"What is unfolding is one of those global financial crises
that start small, but gets suddenly very big." Worldcon is
not yet big enough to justify an all-out bearish attitude, Coxe
cautioned. "It's just one of the hundreds of stories of deceit,
deception and delusion that together defined the tech-telecom mania."
The bank's erstwhile bull, economist Sherry Cooper, declared "the
final stages of the unwinding excesses of the U.S. stock bubble
are upon us." She even suggested gold will act as an "alternative
reserve currency" to the overvalued U.S. dollar.
Stocks sank on cue early yesterday before coming most of the way
back. TheStreet.com observed selling was not panicky enough to declare
capitulation by retail investors.
It may be premature to declare a bottom like the week after Sept.
11, but broadcaster Garth Turner believes we're "at or near"
a bottom. "Except for the 1930s Depression, the U.S. market
has been 40% to 50% higher two years after the kind of slide we
are now experiencing." Investors are shell-shocked but markets
"should bounce off the floor momentarily."
Adrian Mastracci, fee-only investment counsel
at
KCM Wealth Management, says, “Age, risk tolerance and asset
allocation are the critical factors for anxious investors. Asset
mix is crucial. The mix of stocks, bonds and cash determines 94%
of total returns.”
The Successful Investor editor Patrick McKeough agrees "the
WorldCom scandal may be one of those events that occur just as a
market hits bottom."
Not all stocks or sectors bottom at the same time, adds Bob Hoye.
Sir John Templeton always advised buying at the point of maximum
pessimism. That point may have arrived, judging by the fact Templeton
Growth Fund has a position in WorldCom. Templeton Management Ltd.
president Don Reed says the firm is seeing many buying opportunities
lately.
But bears like Dow Theory Letters editor Richard Russell and Weiss
Ratings Inc.'s Martin Weiss are convinced there will be grounds
for more pessimism. Russell insists we are in a long-term bear market
and the trend for stocks and equity mutual funds is therefore down.
Florida-based Weiss says investors are "quickly coming to
the realization corporate earnings and the economy aren't recovering
the way Wall Street said they would. They're getting worse by the
day. Investors are doing the only prudent thing they can -- selling
into any rally."
Advisors worry the baby -- companies with clean accounting practices
-- is being thrown out with the unclean bathwater.
"Frankly, the potential for further huge losses in the [telecom]
sector scares the hell out of me," says advisor Bruce Lindsay,
"That's the real theme in today's trading: let's just sell
off the whole sector and be done with it."
But WorldCom "is no reason to abandon the stock market generally,"
says advisor Jim Rogers, "It is a case for ensuring your portfolio
is broadly diversified, so the difficulties of any one company cannot
have a deleterious effect on your overall portfolio performance."
Age, risk tolerance and asset allocation are the critical factors
for anxious investors. Those at or near retirement should scrutinize
their stock holdings. Anyone needing money within five years should
not be in stocks at all, says Vancouver-based advisor Adrian
Mastracci of KCM Wealth Management.
If your horizon is less than three years, equities should be as
low as 25%, says Vito Maida. Those tempted to buy on weakness should
understand the quality and value of the underlying business they
are contemplating buying, he adds.
Investors must factor in unexpected or prolonged events which significantly
alter expectations. The accounting scandals are one of these, Mastracci
says. He makes two important points:
- Before pressing the panic button, re-examine your long-term
game plan for reaching financial security.
- Asset mix is crucial. The mix of stocks, bonds and cash determines
94% of total returns. Individual stock picks (like WorldCom) account
for 4% of returns, and market timing (like exiting the entire
market over WorldCom) accounts for just 2% of portfolio returns.
Many investors became overweight stocks during the bubble, or gambled
on sectors like telecom. No one security should make up more than
5% of a total portfolio. It's not too late to rebalance, Mastracci
says. "There will be another Worldcom. When it happens you
don't want it to be the one that kills your portfolio."
Author Gordon Pape is "deeply concerned" about the cumulative
impact these revelations are having on investor confidence. Each
"raises more questions about the integrity of the entire market
system. We may see a chill on the stock markets that will last into
2003 at least."
Pape urges selectivity. Review all stock holdings. If you don't
believe in a company for the long term, sell. If you have profits,
sell some of the position.
He suggests avoiding indexes. "Owning some index positions
will be a good strategy when the markets finally turn upwards. But
short term, there appears to be more downside potential here."
Even diversification and "buy and hold" may not be effective,
warns advisor Jack Singer, who expects a 20-year-long bear market.
It's a market for stock pickers and fund pickers, he says. His suggested
asset mix is an eclectic 9% cash, 18% precious metals; 47% resources;
17% high income and 9% real estate.
Advisor Stephen Gadsden says clients should stay the course until
after the third quarter. "It's too late to run for cover and
too precarious to speculate on forthcoming investment opportunities."
|